American Indian Music: Stereotypes and Misconceptions
Increased interest in Native American culture has caused non-Indians to correct many stereotypes of American Indians; non-Indians have learned to appreciate distinctions between the material cultures and beliefs of different tribes. Most people today recognize, for instance, that only a few nations of Native Americans lived in tipis or wore feathered war bonnets. Nevertheless, a general misconception persists that the musical culture of each tribe is the same.
Stereotypes of Indian music began to develop as soon as white settlers arrived in the New World. Most Native American music is sung, and the newcomers naturally compared it to their own vocal traditions of church, concert hall, and salon. For most Europeans, religious music was meant to be dignified, song melodies "pretty," and a singer's voice "beautiful"--meaning rich in vibrato and controlled in volume. It is little wonder, then, that they would find an Indian sacred song--typically rendered at full volume and interspersed with shouts and animal cries--to violate all rules of proper musical performance.